| Name | Sport | Year | Awarded | Where are they now? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mike Geraghty | Baseball | 2010 | All-Conference : 2nd Team | |
| Damon Jenkins | Baseball | 2010 | All-Conference : 2nd Team | Shawnee State |
| Andrew Disbrow | Baseball | 2010 | All-Conference : 2nd Team | |
| Breanna Woods | Tennis | 2010 | All-Conference Team | |
| Veronica VanKirk | Tennis | 2010 | All-Conference Team | |
| Alex Sanchez | Softball | 2010 | All Conference : 1st Team | |
| Samantha Beltran | Softball | 2010 | All Conference : 1st Team | |
| Alexandria Griffin | Softball | 2010 | All Conference : 2nd Team | |
| Tiffany Cole | Softball | 2010 | All Conference : 2nd Team | |
| Deandre Glasper | Football | 2009 | Glenville State | |
| Dion Glasper | Football | 2009 | Glenville State | |
| Anthony Daniels | Football | 2009 | Delta State | |
| Devonte Craig | Football | 2009 | Delta State | |
| Amber Chavez | Basketball | 2009-10 | All Conference : 1st Team | |
| Anastasia Johnson | Basketball | 2009-10 | All Conference : Honorable Mention | |
| Mike Matthews | Football | 2009-10 | New Mexico State | |
| Andrea Warner | Softball | 2009-10 | Bethany College | |
| Anita Espinoza | Softball | 2009 | Bethany College | |
| Jeremy Mireles | Soccer | 2009 | Kansas Wesleyan | |
| Jacob DeLeon | Soccer | 2008-09 | Kansas Wesleyan | |
| Kevin Reay | Soccer | 2008-09 | Kansas Wesleyan | |
| Richard Gonzalez | Soccer | 2009-09 | Kansas Wesleyan | |
| Mario Cisneros | Soccer | 2008-09 | University of LaVerne | |
| Pelton Smalls | Football | 2008-09 | Kansas Wesleyan | |
| Travis Hunter | Football | 2009 | Kansas Wesleyan | |
| Anthony Berry | Football | 2008 | Kansas Wesleyan | |
| Horace Carter | Football | 2009 | Kansas Wesleyan | |
| Alex Mitchell | Football | 2008 | University of Ohio | |
| Donald Fusilier | Football | 2009 | Lindenwood University | |
| Kenny McGrath | Basketball | 2008 | Sterling College | |
| Roderick Milton | Football | 2009 | University of LaVerne |
Last Updated 10/29/19